mmegi

The brilliant conservatism of Justice Kirby’s Court- (Part II)

Justice Kirby handing down his very last judgement on LEGABIBO case PIC: THALEFANG CHARLES
Justice Kirby handing down his very last judgement on LEGABIBO case PIC: THALEFANG CHARLES

By and large his record in public law was a mixed one. In public law some lawyers tended to think he would fit the category of the judges that Lord Atkin considered executive minded - and perhaps even more than the executive.

Jurisprudentially a close academic scrutiny of his judgements; how he elected to exercise the options before him in any case reveal him as being inclined to legal positivism. In many high stake cases of national importance his deference to the executive was often undisguised.

The case in point was the case of Bopeu v the Attorney General. At issue was whether the dismissal of the public sector employees who embarked on a strike to press home their demands for better working conditions were lawfully dismissed. They had contended before the High Court and the Court of Appeal that their dismissal was unlawful because a hearing did not precede it.

Editor's Comment
Justice delayed is trust denied

Batswana who marched peacefully for 'Justice for Tshepi' demanded answers. They have now received a detailed account of police investigation and a promise that the file is with the Directorate of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The real test is whether the state now keeps its word without further prodding. In his address, the minister asked the nation to trust the process. He spoke of rigour, not neglect, and pointed to 10 months of...

Have a Story? Send Us a tip
arrow up