mmegi

Merit-based elevation to the bench

Oftentimes, governments are accused of appointing loyal marionettes to the highest court. This view is rooted in the belief that, in an environment where the judiciary is compromised, some judges might feel compelled to dance to the tune of the executive, thereby abetting the repugnant culture of executive overreach and impunity by officialdom.

Perhaps it is the aversion for an unaccountable elite club of aggressive and oppressive untouchables, that motivated Lord Bingham, the former Senior Law Lord with the House of Lords, to intone, “There are countries where the judges always agree with the government, but they are not countries in which anyone of us would wish to live.”

I have been watching with keen interest the grilling of Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson by the Senate Judiciary Committee of the US Congress. The committee comprises 22 Senators, some of whom have earned their appointment to the committee because of their strong legal background. History is in the making as Judge Jackson is the first black woman to be nominated for the Supreme Court, thanks to Joe Biden’s fulfilment of the promise he made on his campaign trail.

Editor's Comment
BPF should get house in order

Speaker of the National Assembly, Dithapelo Keorapetse, has this week rightly washed his hands of the mess, refusing to wade into a party squabble that has no clear leadership and no single version of the truth.When a single party sends six different letters to the Speaker’s office, each claiming to be the authoritative voice, it is not just confusion, but an embarrassment.Keorapetse is correct to insist on institutional boundaries. Parliament...

Have a Story? Send Us a tip
arrow up