Matambo's budget: some lessons from the bible
Wednesday, May 08, 2013
The seven fat cows meant harvests would be good for seven years and that this would be followed by seven years of bad harvests. Joseph advised pharaoh that what needed to be done was to preserve a 20% share of the nation's grain in preparation for the bad times. Pharaoh appointed Joseph to oversee what was the world's first documented sovereign wealth fund, where wealth from today is stored for the future. Non-economists joke that in over 3,000 years since Joseph, economists have still not developed more scientific or accurate methods of prediction than Joseph's reading of pharaoh's dream.
The biblical parallel to Botswana's budget and its current situation could not be more pointed. The Minister of Finance, Kenneth Matambo presented a budget this week that few could possibly challenge - the budget was balanced, there was a small surplus and there were no tax increases. What more could one reasonably ask?Botswana remains with a public debt of just 23% of GDP, the envy of many heavily indebted countries in Europe or North America where debt as a percentage of GDP is in many cases well over 100%. The only tax measure introduced by Matambo was in effect a decrease in taxes with taxes on interest income earned from savings was set at a final rate of 10%. Of course this is cold solace for savers as commercial bank deposit rates are so low in Botswana, well below the rate of inflation and anyone who saves their money in a bank gets poorer, in real terms, every year. It would of course have been better had Governor Linah Mohohlo used her considerable powers of persuasion on the commercial banks to raise deposit rates so that savers have some incentives to save rather than buy cars and more consumer goods.
Instead, it has sparked a storm of accusations, denials, and unresolved questions about the influence of De Beers on the nation’s politics. Former president Mokgweetsi Masisi’s claims that the diamond giants bankrolled his removal to dodge taxes – and that the new Umbrella for Democratic Change (UDC) government watered down a favourable diamond deal – are explosive matters. But without evidence, they risk becoming a toxic distraction from...