Latest News

Botswana National Front Central Committee (BNFCC) over the weekend res...
Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has raised a concern over the rising n...
Botswana Prisons Service has committed to start a video conferencing f...
The High Court has for the second time interdicted the Botswana Red Cr...

Govt Ĺtricksĺ Mwale in ARV case

Gift Mwale
The Attorney General has urgently appealed a High Court ruling passed last week ordering government to provide foreign prisoners with free Antiretroviral (ARVs) medication.

The appeal was made a day after the judgment.

On Monday, Attorney Chuchuchu Nchunga Nchunga, wrote to prisoner Gift Mwale’s lawyers requesting a meeting, which he said, was in order for the government to comply with Judge Key Dingake judgment in favour of the provision of ARVs to foreign prisoners.

“In compliance with the judgment of Justice Dingake, in the above mentioned case, we wish to notify you that there is an urgent need to meet in the presence of our clients to agree on the practicalities of providing your client with the requisite medication (ARVs) as ordered by the court. In this regard kindly arrange with my secretary to arrange a mutually convenient time when we can meet to progress implementation. We would be grateful if you respond immediately upon receipt of his letter,” reads the letter.

However, a day later, Yarona Sharp, an attorney with the AGs chambers, filed government’s appeal against Dingake’s judgment. The appeal was filed shortly before 1100hrs last Tuesday.

The urgent appeal will be presented before Court of Appeal president Justice Ian Kirby on Tuesday. In the appeal, Sharp noted that government is unhappy with Justice Dingake’s judgment, and does not see a constitutional basis for Mwale’s claims.

The AG’s grounds of appeal are that the Dingake gravely erred in proclaiming that Mwale was being unfairly discriminated against and that discrimination was unfair because it serves no legitimate purpose and bears no rationale connection, the differentiation and the purpose.

“The court completely misdirected  itself  when it held that the discrimination that the applicant (Mwale) has suffered is plainly unlawful because it is not mandated by the constitution, particularly section 15,” she said.

Sharp also said that Justice Dingake erred in finding that Mwale had presented a compelling case and ought to succeed in the relief he sought. ‘‘The court did not appreciate the appellants’’ pleadings and the evidence adduced before

it in stating that it is justified

The AG also in its notice is appealing the interlocutory ruling issued on April 23, 2015 saying the court erred in granting the ruling.

Justice Dingake had given the ruling, which pronounced that Mwale’s application was different from the one that was before Justice Terrence Rannoane.” He had pointed out that Mwale was only joined as respondent in a contempt of court brought by a civic organisation. “It becomes plain therefore that the application that the applicant has brought seeks wide ranging relief, fundamentally different from the one brought by BONELA in the contempt application. The cause of action and the relief sought is fundamentally different,” she said.

This was after the AG had made an application stating that Mwale’s application was the same as that before Justice Rannoane and that he will benefit from its judgment.

Mwale, who is backed by BONELA and currently serving a seven year sentence for robbery, had filed an urgent application demanding among other things, to be either released from jail so that he can fend for himself and obtain ARV drugs, or that the state be forced to provide him with the treatment.

Mwale had filed the application citing that he was diagnosed with HIV while in prison, and it had progressed to full-blown AIDS, which had led him to self-enroll on treatment which set him back P3,500 per month. He had sought to be enrolled on government’s ARV programme as he said could no longer foot the costs for the expensive treatment as it had exhausted his savings.

Mwale’s application was lodged concurrently with that of other foreign inmates living with HIV, who had approached the courts seeking that government be held in contempt for defying an order issued by Justice Sechele in August, which had stipulated that they be provided with free ARV like local prisoners.


Banners ?>



Latest Frontpages

Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper
Adana Escort Ad─▒yaman Escort Afyon Escort A─čr─▒ Escort Aksaray Escort Amasya Escort Ankara Escort Antalya Escort Antep Escort Ardahan Escort Artvin Escort Ayd─▒n Escort Bal─▒kesir Escort Bart─▒n Escort Batman Escort Bayburt Escort Bilecik Escort Bing├Âl Escort Bitlis Escort Bolu Escort Burdur Escort Bursa Escort ├çanakkale Escort ├çank─▒r─▒ Escort ├çorum Escort Denizli Escort Diyarbak─▒r Escort D├╝zce Escort Edirne Escort Erzincan Escort Elaz─▒─č Escort Erzurum Escort Eski┼čehir Escort Giresun Escort G├╝m├╝┼čhane Escort Hakkari Escort Hatay Escort I─čd─▒r Escort Isparta Escort ─░skenderun Escort ─░stanbul Escort ─░zmir Escort ─░zmit Escort Karab├╝k Escort Karaman Escort Kars Escort Kastamonu Escort Kayseri Escort K─▒br─▒s Escort K─▒r─▒kkale Escort K─▒rklareli Escort K─▒r┼čehir Escort Kilis Escort Kocaeli Escort Konya Escort K├╝tahya Escort Malatya Escort Manisa Escort Mara┼č Escort Mardin Escort Mersin Escort Mu─čla Escort Mu┼č Escort Nev┼čehir Escort Ni─čde Escort Ordu Escort Osmaniye Escort Rize Escort Sakarya Escort Samsun Escort Siirt Escort Sinop Escort Sivas Escort ┼×─▒rnak Escort Tekirda─č Escort Tokat Escort Trabzon Escort Tunceli Escort Urfa Escort U┼čak Escort Van Escort Yalova Escort Yozgat Escort Zonguldak Escort Ala├žat─▒ Escort Alia─ča Escort Alsancak Escort Bornova Escort Buca Escort ├çe┼čme Escort ├çi─čli Escort Gaziemir Escort Kar┼č─▒yaka Escort fethiye escort iskenderun escort iskenderun escort iskenderun escort iskenderun escort iskenderun escort