Last Updated
Friday 19 December 2014, 09:33 am.
Local banks immune to SA rating downgrades

Local commercial banks will not be affected by this week's viability downgrading of five commercial banks in South Africa, despite three of them having subsidiaries in Botswana, analysts reckon.
By Staff Writer Mon 22 Dec 2014, 13:58 pm (GMT +2)
Mmegi Online :: Local banks immune to SA rating downgrades








 Due to its heavy dependence on South Africa, Botswana has perennially suffered spillover effects of most negative events in Africa's biggest economy ranging from fuel, electricity and food shortages caused by labour unrests or other disruptions.

On Wednesday, three of Botswana's top four banks had viability ratings of their South African based parent companies downgraded, following last week's downgrading of that country's sovereign rating.

 The banks involved are Absa, FirstRand and Standard Bank, which are the parent companies to Botswana's Barclays, FNB and Stanbic respectively.

In spite of the three holding majority shareholding in local banks, economist Keith Jefferis says local banks are independently capitalised and regulated so there is bound to be no spillover effect from the ratings downgrades.

"The banks' downgrading stems largely from last week's similar action on South Africa's sovereign ratings. So the factors are only concentrated in that country. It could obviously have an impact if those banks were to go bust, but this downgrading is not such a major issue, which will at most only increase their costs when they want to raise  capital," he said.

Fitch said the downgrade of the banks' viability ratings reflected their concentration in South Africa, a high proportion of liquid assets invested in government securities and a weakening operating environment, as indicated by the downgrade of the sovereign rating.

"The sovereign rating is now effectively acting as a cap on these banks' viability ratings at this rating level because of their strong links with South Africa," Fitch said.

In cutting South Africa's sovereign rating to BBB, the agency said social and political tension had increased. Subdued growth coupled with rising corruption had constrained the ability to raise living standards, reduce the unemployment rate and redress historical inequalities, Fitch said.

Botswana has five entities of the 11 South African finance groups operating in Africa, including Standard Bank, First Rand, Investec and Sanlam.

Local data indicates that by June 30, 2012, First Rand's local subsidiary held 25.4 percent of non-bank deposits in Botswana, while Standard Bank's subsidiary held 16.3 percent.

 An executive with one of the three banks affected, who declined to be named, also echoed Jefferis sentiments, saying the local subsidiaries operate in a totally different environment, which is not affected by events in South Africa.

"The operating environment here is totally separated from that of the parent companies with different regulators and sources of capital. I do not expect any effect on us at all," he said.

In a recent research paper, the IMF noted that the direct spillover risk from South African banks is limited as most are funded from local deposits as opposed to cross-border loans. "Moreover, in the event of cross-border lending or deposit taking, the scale in Botswana is minimal when compared to the assets of the South African banking system," said the IMF.

 In the research paper published last November, the IMF said the anticipated slowdown in the South African economy this year would restrain growth in Botswana through spillovers into trade, capital flows and remittances.



Exchange Rates
FOREIGN EXCHANGE: Monday, 22 Dec 2014
FOREIGN / PULA
PULA / FOREIGN
1 USD = Pula   9.4967
1 GBP = Pula   14.8588
1 EUR = Pula   11.6414
1 YEN = Pula   0.0795
1 ZAR = Pula   0.8203
1 Pula = USD   0.1053
1 Pula = GBP   0.0673
1 Pula = EUR   0.0859
1 Pula = YEN   12.58
1 Pula = ZAR   1.219
Banner Image
Stock Exchange
STOCK EXCHANGE: Friday, 19 Dec 2014
DOMESTIC STOCKS
ABCH
714
BARCLAYS
343
BIHL
1151
CHOBE
427
CHOPPIES
406
CRESTA
89
ENGEN
950
FNBB
362
FSG
237
FURNMART
220
G4S
374
LETLOLE
215
LETSHEGO
266
NAP
217
OLYMPIA
20
PRIMETIME
260
RDCP
202
SECHABA
2810
SEFALANA
922
STANCHART
1258
TURNSTAR
208
WIL
310
IMARA
210
  • Previous
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb Poster
    Next
    Masa Centre
    ::: Friday 19 Dec - Tuesday 23 Dec :::
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb
    John Wick
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
    Love, Rosie
    Penguins of Madagascar
  • Previous
    John Wick Poster
    Next
    Riverwalk
    ::: Friday 19 Dec - Tuesday 23 Dec :::
    John Wick
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
    Walking on Sunshine
    Penguins of Madagascar
  • Previous
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb Poster
    Next
    Gamecity
    ::: Friday 19 Dec - Tuesday 23 Dec :::
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb
    John Wick
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
    Penguins of Madagascar
    Love, Rosie
    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1