Features

Paris diamond signing: What’s the big deal?

Details matter: Pepper says consumers should never be left in doubt about what they are buying
 
Details matter: Pepper says consumers should never be left in doubt about what they are buying

Mmegi: In the Diamond Collective's view, what is the importance of preserving the definition of diamonds to mean only natural diamonds and no other?

Pepper: First and foremost, the words we use shape how consumers understand what they are buying. Language is not just a matter of terminology, but it also tells us something fundamental about a product, including where it comes from, how it was created and what makes it distinct.

That matters enormously for diamonds because a natural diamond is not just defined by how it looks. Its origin is intrinsic to what it is – a rare, finite creation of the Earth, formed over billions of years and inherently unique. That provenance is inseparable from the meaning, wonder and value people have associated with diamonds for generations.

We know that natural and synthetic diamonds have fundamentally different origins and are different products. Being clear about that distinction is not about limiting choice; it is about giving consumers the transparency and information they need to understand the difference and choose with confidence.

That is why the declaration from France and Botswana matters. By reaffirming that the word ‘diamond’, used on its own, refers to a natural diamond, it does more than protect a definition. It provides greater clarity for consumers while preserving the identity, provenance and extraordinary story that belong uniquely to diamonds formed by nature.

Mmegi: We are informed that other key diamond retail areas such as Belgium (possibly) and the US (to an extent) have either committed to a similar definition or are considering that. To your knowledge, how far have these efforts progressed?

Pepper: Approaches inevitably vary from market to market, but what is encouraging is the growing recognition of a very simple principle: consumers should never be left in doubt about what they are buying.

We are seeing greater focus across a number of important diamond markets on establishing terminology that clearly distinguishes diamonds formed by nature from products created in a laboratory. The regulatory frameworks may differ, but the direction of travel towards greater clarity and transparency is important.

In the US, for example, the Federal Trade Commission’s Jewelry Guides state that a laboratory-grown product should not be described using the word ‘diamond’ on its own, without a clear qualifier, and that terms such as ‘real’, ‘genuine’ and ‘natural’ should be reserved for natural diamonds.

In Belgium, jewellers have been legally required since May 2023 to give customers a document stating whether a diamond is natural or synthetic. In March this year, Economy Minister David Clarinval said he wants to examine whether the term ‘diamond’ could be reserved exclusively for natural diamonds.

For us, the significance is bigger than any one market or individual piece of regulation. This is about building greater consistency in how we talk about two different products, so that consumers can immediately understand their origin and make an informed choice.

Mmegi: The Diamond Collective as the former Natural Diamond Council, fought against efforts by synthetic producers to market their products as natural diamonds. Please share an update on any ongoing processes and the reason why this is critical for natural producers?

Pepper: We believe there is always room for consumer choice, but there should never be room for consumer confusion. That really is the principle at the heart of our position. Natural and synthetic diamonds have different origins and different journeys to the consumer. Being clear about those differences is not about diminishing one product in favour of another; it is about giving each the confidence to stand on what makes it distinct.

For natural diamonds, that origin carries an extraordinary story. They are rare, finite products of the Earth, formed over billions of years. But their value reaches far beyond their beauty and rarity. Across many diamond-producing countries, the story does not begin or end at the jewellery counter - the natural diamond industry is connected to livelihoods, communities and wider economic development. We believe that when consumers understand that provenance, they can begin to understand the wider story too.

The Diamond Collective is not here to prescribe consumer choice. We are here to champion transparency, celebrate what makes natural diamonds extraordinary and ensure their story is told with confidence and accuracy. Different products can, and should, coexist, but they should do so on the strength of their own stories, with consumers empowered to understand the difference and decide for themselves.

Mmegi: Kindly shed any light you can on the progress the Luanda Accord has made and is making in leading a global fightback by natural diamonds?

Pepper: The Luanda Accord, signed in Luanda last June, was a landmark moment for our industry. Diamond-producing governments and industry stakeholders came together to commit to renewed and sustained investment in global category marketing for natural diamonds. Participating producer governments and De Beers Group intend to allocate 1% of the annual revenue they generate from rough diamond sales to fund this initiative, entrusted to what was then the Natural Diamond Council and is now The Diamond Collective.

Since then, the Accord has continued to grow, with Angola’s ENDIAMA and SODIAM joining us as members in January this year. In February, Namibia formally became a signatory, joining Angola, Botswana and the Democratic Republic of Congo, and in May India’s GJEPC, the first industry body to progress toward membership under the Luanda Accord framework, also officially joined us. When we met again in Luanda earlier this month, hosted by Hon. Diamantino Azevedo, we reviewed 2026 and aligned on our strategy for 2027.

A true collective, this is producers investing together in the natural diamond story. What I see is confidence in the industry, unity and solidarity, and a clear view of impact, with African nations influencing global markets. Together, we are bigger than the sum of our parts.

Mmegi: We are seeing interesting trends in both production and sales this year or at least in the first half of the year. Would you say some shoots of recovery are taking hold and what is required to firm this growth?

Pepper: There are certainly encouraging signals, but we should distinguish between green shoots and declaring a recovery. We are seeing pockets of resilience in pricing and demand, particularly in parts of the polished market and for higher-value natural diamonds, but the picture remains uneven, and there are still very real pressures across the value chain. For us, the more important question is what turns those early signs of momentum into sustainable, long-term growth. And ultimately, that comes back to demand.

We need to give people compelling reasons to choose diamonds. Consumer behaviour is constantly changing, particularly among Gen Z. The way younger audiences discover luxury, the people and platforms they trust, and the things they choose to invest meaning and value in are all evolving. Our opportunity is to understand those shifts and make sure diamonds remain part of the cultural and emotional conversations that matter to them.

That is exactly why we are developing the Diamond Desire Index. For the first time, we want to build a consistent picture of desire for diamonds among Gen Z and Millennials across the globe, looking at consideration and purchase intent alongside the perceptions, behaviours and influences shaping that desire.

The Index will give us an evidence base to understand where desire is growing, where barriers remain and where investment can have the greatest impact. It will also allow us to move beyond instinct and measure whether the work we are doing is actually changing how people feel about diamonds and, ultimately, whether that desire is translating into demand.

We are optimistic about the opportunity ahead, but lasting recovery will not happen by itself. We have to create it, by rebuilding desire, strengthening relevance and giving a new generation their own reasons to choose diamonds.