News

‘Botswana’s business environment hostile’

Mokgware. PIC PHATSIMO KAPENG
 
Mokgware. PIC PHATSIMO KAPENG

Labour and Home Affairs minister Pius Mokgware, however, is standing firm on government’s drive to reserve more jobs for Batswana. Whilst employers say they need experienced personnel to run and expand their businesses, Mokgware has told Parliament that staffing quotas are also being enforced to protect opportunities for citizens, signalling continued pressure on companies to recruit locally. The minister has confirmed that government has stopped issuing permits for certain occupations and is enforcing staffing quotas to increase opportunities for citizens. Business executives, however, say companies are struggling to bring in experienced personnel needed to run operations and support expansion.

Lucara Botswana managing director, Naseem Lahri, said Botswanas business environment was still hostile to investments. She bemoaned that one of the main worries of the private sector was the ability to get talent into the country to advance their interests. “The current business environment is not conducive for businesses to thrive, even getting specialised skills into the country to further operations is difficult,” she said at the Botswana Development Corporation's investment forum last week. “It’s a struggle to get permits for the labour we need and operations end up stalling.” A private sector executive, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told Mmegi that investors seeking to enter Botswana wanted to bring experienced personnel from operations they already knew. The executive argued that previous working relationships gave investors confidence in the people entrusted with their money. “We have investments we want to bring into the country, but we need permits for people who have experience in these industries so that they can protect our money.

“We trust them because we have worked with them on other operations for years,” the executive added. Mokgware said assessments had identified occupations for which permits would no longer be issued. “We have done assessments and seen that there are jobs where we don’t want expatriates on. Jobs such as heavy duty drivers and teaching we have stopped issuing out permits for such jobs and we expect the numbers to keep going down,” he said.

The minister was responding to a supplementary question from Kgatleng Central MP Mpho Morolong on whether government was using permit restrictions to accelerate citizen employment. Mokgware also said government was enforcing staffing quotas to limit the exclusion of Batswana from employment. His remarks indicate that employers’ difficulties are unfolding alongside a deliberate push to reduce reliance on foreign workers in occupations government believes citizens can fill. The dispute concerns the application of Botswana’s localisation policy, which gives citizens preference in employment whilst allowing companies to recruit expatriates where suitable skills are unavailable. Foreign recruitment is meant to be accompanied by training that prepares Batswana to eventually take over those positions. In an April parliamentary response, the Labour ministry reiterated that expatriates could work in sectors lacking trained personnel, with the expectation that they would train citizens and make way once local replacements were ready. The policy therefore, depends on assessing both the immediate skills shortage and progress towards replacing foreign expertise The permit restrictions also extend to compliance with Botswana’s labour standards.

Addressing the North West District Council in Maun in September, Mokgware said tourism companies that mistreated employees would be denied work permits. He said investigations had uncovered abuses, including efforts to prevent workers from joining trade unions. “We have taken a decision that we will not grant work permits to companies that mistreat their employees,” Mokgware said at the time. The warning tied access to expatriate labour to employers’ treatment of their existing workforce. However, the minister’s written response to Parliament also acknowledged that some expatriates possess experience that local workers may not yet have, including workers without formal qualifications. The response distinguishes formal certification from skills acquired through practical experience. In a parliamentary response to a question by Hon Morolong, Mokgware reported 4,276 foreign nationals classified as non-skilled, comprising farm workers and mining workers with specialised experience but no formal or vocational certification.

He said these workers had acquired experience and skills through in-house training. A further 2,645 semi-skilled foreign nationals worked as technicians, mainly in construction and mining. Mokgware said these workers were trained in areas where local employees might not have had exposure or experience. Together, the two categories account for 6,921 people. The minister specified that the figures concerned active work and residence permit holders for 2022–2026; they do not represent the entire expatriate workforce or the number of applications recently approved.

The restrictions on teachers and truck drivers also predate the latest parliamentary exchange. In January 2025, Mokgware told protesting unemployed teachers that government had stopped issuing permits for foreign educators and truck drivers, placing the measures within its effort to protect local employment. The teachers had pressed government to prioritise unemployed Batswana educators, illustrating the competing demands facing the ministry. Employers calls for access to foreign personnel now sit alongside pressure from citizens seeking opportunities in occupations for which they have trained.