News

FMD crisis: P97m war, beef industry on its knees

Boko has disclosed that government has pumped P97 million into fighting the FMD outbreak PIC: MORERI SEJAKGOMO
 
Boko has disclosed that government has pumped P97 million into fighting the FMD outbreak PIC: MORERI SEJAKGOMO

Speaking during the State of the Nation Address (SONA) on Monday, Boko disclosed that government has pumped P97 million into fighting the outbreak. The staggering figures expose the enormous economic cost of an outbreak that has paralysed cattle movements, disrupted beef exports and left farmers counting losses. With abattoir offtake falling approximately 93% short of the target, the crisis has raised fresh questions about the effectiveness of government's disease-control strategy, the deployment of emergency funding and how much longer the country's cattle industry can withstand the economic punishment. For a country whose beef industry remains a critical source of rural livelihoods, employment and export earnings, the figures paint a troubling picture of an agricultural sector struggling to regain its footing. 'The FMD outbreak in Zones 11 and 13 dealt a severe blow to our beef industry, halting exports and reducing abattoir offtake to 4,725 tonnes against a target of 70,000 tonnes,' Boko told Parliament. “We responded by deploying P97 million emergency funding and continue to commit additional resources to fight the outbreak. Through rezoning and intensified surveillance, we are restoring Botswana’s FMD-free status.

' The President's admission comes against the backdrop of growing frustrations amongst cattle farmers, feedlot operators and opposition politicians, who are questioning whether the government's costly containment measures are delivering results timeously. While Boko highlighted the emergency funding, his address did not provide a breakdown of how the P97 million has been spent, which interventions have received the largest allocations or how much additional funding government intends to commit. The absence of those details leaves important accountability questions unanswered, particularly as farmers continue to shoulder the financial consequences of movement restrictions.

P97 million under scrutiny The emergency funding has become a significant issue in the increasingly contentious debate over Botswana's response to FMD. Botswana Congress Party (BCP), through its shadow minister for Lands and Agriculture, Kesitegile Gobotswang, has previously demanded that government account to Parliament for the P97 million committed to combating the disease. Gobotswang has questioned the effectiveness of the country's disease-control structures, arguing that resources should be directed towards practical veterinary interventions rather than administrative arrangements.

He has also called for the abolition of the National and District FMD Command Centres, accusing them of becoming costly political structures instead of effective disease-control mechanisms. According to Gobotswang, resources should be redirected towards the Department of Veterinary Services to strengthen surveillance, early detection, rapid response, biosecurity and the rehabilitation of cordon fences. His criticism has been particularly pointed because the outbreak has persisted despite emergency vaccinations, movement controls and intensified surveillance. 'Eight months later, transmission is still active in the south. This is not misfortune. This is neglect, dressed up as a response,' Gobotswang said in an earlier criticism of government's handling of the outbreak.

However, the government's position has consistently been that strict movement restrictions, vaccination and surveillance remain necessary to prevent the disease from spreading into areas that have remained free of infection. Despite the devastating figures presented by Boko, the Ministry of Lands and Agriculture has reported significant progress in the disease containment. In an October 30, 2026 press release, the ministry announced that the last recorded FMD case was on October 10 in Kgatleng, where vaccination was continuing.

It further reported that the disease remained suppressed in Zones 3c, covering Maitengwe, and 6b in the North East District, where no outbreaks had been recorded since March 16, 2026. Within the containment zone, the last recorded case was on September 12, 2026. Nevertheless, the ministry maintained that movement into and out of the containment zone remained restricted. Under the revised arrangements, cattle and small stock could be moved directly to registered slaughter facilities within the containment zone under permit. Only cattle vaccinated three times against FMD, bearing the required vaccination brands and registered in the Botswana Animal Identification and Traceability System (BAITS 3), were eligible for slaughter.

The ministry also relaxed certain slaughter restrictions in Zone 11, excluding Kgatleng, areas east of the A1 and specified extension areas. For Zones 9 and 10, covering Tsabong District and Tuli Block farms, the ministry reported that no cases had been recorded. The first vaccination round had been completed, with the second scheduled for completion in November. Gov’t opens limited meat trade In a follow-up statement issued on November 3, the ministry further clarified arrangements governing the movement of meat products from affected and restricted zones.

Under the revised guidelines, matured deboned beef derived from cattle resident inside the containment zone may be moved to other parts of the country, subject to a 30-day quarantine period, permits and seals. Thoroughly cooked meat and brittle dry biltong are also permitted to move under specified conditions. The ministry additionally authorised certain movements of bone-in meat from livestock originating in specified zones and slaughtered at designated abattoirs, subject to the applicable restrictions. In Zones 11 and 13, thoroughly cooked meat and brittle dry biltong may be moved to the rest of the country without permits. However, the government has introduced a quota system for authorised slaughter facilities to prevent overcrowding and slaughter backlogs. 'No farmer would be issued a movement without a quota from a slaughter facility,' the ministry stated.

The quota requirement introduces another important consideration for farmers desperate to sell cattle after months of restricted movement. While the easing of restrictions potentially creates opportunities for livestock sales, access to slaughter facilities will depend on available capacity and compliance with veterinary requirements. For farmers whose animals have remained unsold for extended periods, the speed at which slaughter facilities can accommodate livestock will be critical. Behind the government's containment measures lies an increasingly difficult economic reality for farmers and businesses dependent on cattle production. In September, the financial consequences of movement restrictions were laid bare before the Gaborone High Court when feedlot operators JS Beef (Pty) Ltd and Primefast (Pty) Ltd challenged restrictions affecting their livestock.

The companies disclosed that approximately 6,600 cattle had remained in their facilities for more than 200 days beyond their intended slaughter dates. They estimated additional feeding costs at approximately P27 million.

Their urgent application sought permission to slaughter or export the cattle, arguing that they were not attempting to dismantle the government's wider FMD control strategy. However, Justice Onkemetse Tshosa dismissed the application on September 1, finding that the matter did not satisfy the legal requirements for urgency. For feedlot operators, prolonged restrictions mean continuing to feed animals that would ordinarily have entered the market. For ordinary farmers, cattle represent are a source of income, savings, collateral and financial security. When cattle cannot be moved or sold, farmers may struggle to meet household expenses, service debts or finance agricultural operations. The economic consequences extend to transporters, abattoirs, meat processors and other businesses dependent on livestock trading. Political battle over restrictions The FMD crisis has also become a source of political confrontation following government's decision to temporarily relax certain slaughter restrictions during Botswana's Independence celebrations.

The arrangement, which ran until October 5, permitted cattle and small stock slaughter for social events and personal consumption in much of Zone 11, subject to strict conditions. The BCP seized on the temporary concession, arguing that government had effectively demonstrated that controlled slaughter could be conducted safely. Dr Kesitlegile Gobotswang accused the administration of applying inconsistent standards by permitting slaughter for celebrations while maintaining restrictions affecting farmers' commercial activities. 'If on-farm slaughter and permit-free movement of fresh product inside Zone 11 are safe enough for Independence gatherings, they are safe enough for a household that has to eat and a farmer who has to sell. The virus does not become dangerous again on October 6,' he argued. The opposition's criticism centered on whether government should adopt a more targeted approach that distinguishes between areas where outbreaks remain active and those where surveillance has not detected the disease.

Government, however, has maintained that disease-control measures must be informed by veterinary assessments and the need to protect areas that remain free of FMD. But with abattoir offtake falling dramatically short of the national target, the challenge facing government extends beyond containing the disease. The reported absence of new cases in several zones provides grounds for cautious optimism, while the controlled reopening of slaughter and meat movements offers a possible route towards economic recovery. However, the emergence of fresh cases in Kgatleng as recently as October underscores the danger of assuming that the outbreak has been completely defeated.