News

Dawnbell takes copyright royalty fight to High Court

Ndiko
 
Ndiko

In an appeal filed on October 8, 2026, the academy seeks to overturn a decision delivered by the Magistrate’s Court on September 21, 2026, in a dispute that raises questions about the identification of protected literary works, the collection of royalties and the obligations of institutions using copyrighted material. Dawn Bell lost the legal battle and was ordered to pay over P38, 000 and the academy, represented by Ndadi Law Firm, is challenging the ruling of the lower court. It argues in court papers that the decision effectively imposed liability without requiring COSBOTS to disclose the materials and authors on which its claim was based.

“The court a quo erred in holding that the appellant was liable to pay the respondent royalties over materials and authors that were neither disclosed neither to the court nor to the Appellant,” reads one of the grounds of appeal. The academy argues that without such disclosure, COSBOTS’ claim cannot stand because its source remains undisclosed. “In the absence of such disclosure, the cause of action would be unsustainable as the source of the claim is undisclosed,” the appeal states.

The matter stems from a claim by COSBOTS for royalties over literary works allegedly attracting copyright payments. The dispute reached the Mogoditshane Magistrate’s Court, where the academy was dissatisfied with the judgment delivered on September 21, 2026 by Mogoditshane Chief Magistrate Gofaone Morweng. At the centre of the disagreement is whether COSBOTS sufficiently identified the works and authors underpinning its claim and demonstrated that the materials fell within its mandate to collect royalties. Dawn Bell now wants the High Court to overturn the decision and send the matter back to the lower court for continuation of the proceedings. The dispute also centres on the interpretation of Section 35(2) of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act, with the academy disputing the lower court’s approach to internationally protected works. According to the appeal, the court erred by effectively accepting that all internationally protected works fell under COSBOTS’ collection mandate without requiring the society to identify the works and establish the basis for their protection. The academy argues that the provision requires COSBOTS to identify the protected works before invoking the relevant international convention or agreement. “In the absence of a Replication, the Respondent did not show that the royalties claimed are from works protected under international conventions or any other agreement,” the grounds state.

Another point of contention is the lower court’s position on the responsibility of the academy to maintain a catalogue of literary works used at its institution, including details of authors and publishers. Dawn Bell challenges that position, arguing that it wrongly presupposes that all works are protected and that COSBOTS is entitled to collect royalties for every author. “This is not so as the Respondent collects royalties for authors it has an agreement with. (its members),” the appeal states, citing Sections 36A (2)(c) and 36B(2) of the Act. The academy’s position is that the collection of royalties should be linked to the works and authors falling within the society’s mandate, rather than a blanket assumption that all literary material attracts payments through COSBOTS. It also disputes the lower court’s handling of the claim, arguing that the court upheld COSBOTS’s exception despite the academy having denied the claim.

“The court erred in upholding the Respondent’s exception despite the claim being denied, but only on the strength of an invoice generated by the Respondent itself, which at law amounts to self-help,” the appeal states. The academy maintains that the claim had not yet been proved at trial, challenging the reliance on an invoice generated by the society itself. In its application to the High Court, Dawn Bell wants the appeal to succeed and the Magistrates’ Court decision of September 21, 2026, to be set aside.

It is also seeking an order replacing the lower court’s decision with one dismissing COSBOTS’ exception with costs, as well as an order remitting the matter to the Magistrates’ Court for continuation of the action. The academy further wants COSBOTS to pay the costs of the appeal.