Legislative scheme was unconstitutional- COA

Delivering the judgement, Judge President Tebogo Tau said this was in violation of the protections of the right to property enshrined under section 8 of the constitution. “Based on the evidence on record, the farm was not purchased from the tribe. It was acquired by the land board through an act of Parliament without the consent of the Tribe. That in itself gave rise to compulsory acquisition,” Tau said.

She stated that section 8 prohibits compulsory acquisition unless certain conditions are met such as where acquisition is necessary and expedient and cogent reason has been provided for doing so and where payment or compensation for compulsory acquisition has been provided. Agreeing with the outcome reached in the judgement, Judge Isaac Lesetedi who was part of the five CoA bench said there was no evidence of any consultation with the tribe let alone the consent.