Latest News

Local female rapper Sasa Klaas (Sarona Motlhagodi) of Mmamongwato fame...
Former African champion, Isaac Makwala has approached the Botswana Ath...
The Botswana National Sport Commission (BNSC) has suspended Botswana A...
FRANCISTOWN: The country’s history is littered with tales of pla...

Friends and Enemies with Attack as the Best Means of Defence

Perhaps you also read it and were similarly incredulous. I am, of course referring to the Weekend Postĺs report of the meeting of the DIS Director with the National Assemblyĺs Public Accounts Committee (May 21-27).

None of us, surely, could have read this article without wanting to know a great deal more. But instead of each one of us talking to ourselves, as has been the unavoidable pattern in the past, there must be a chance that Dithapelo Keorapetse can give us some answers.

He, at least, has broken entirely new ground by regularly telling us, as an MP and not just as a reporter, what actually happens in the National Assembly. And we have gained immeasurably from those reports.

Now, therefore, instead of all the usual navel gazing stuff, I am hoping that he will kindly explain to us how, in terms of policy and oversight, this security thing really works. Or doesn’t. Thus the DIS Director refused to answer questions about costs on security grounds. And could, I suppose, refuse also to answer questions from the National Assembly’s Intelligence and Security Parliamentary Committee, were it to meet, because it has no responsibility for finance?

If, for whatever reason, he cannot account to the two Committees, it would seem that Parliament itself has no role in respect of the country’s security?

Is this possible? Is ensuring the security of the people of this country so sensitive that even our elected representatives must not be allowed to know what measures have been taken, why they have been taken and at what cost? In theory, the National Assembly annually approves the budget for the DIS and the one and only means available to it to re-gain its lost control would be to refuse its approval. But would this work? Money now seems to be awash all over the place and the government appears to have no difficulty obtaining whatever it needs without need of Parliamentary approval.

But is the policy for defence and security also outside the responsibility of the National Assembly? The Director stated that, ‘we need more spending on defence and security firstly because the national budget on security organs including the BDF, Police and Prisons is very small and secondly because ,‘our friends can be our enemies tomorrow and we need to be prepared militarily’. Here then is a straightforward policy statement which embraces both the DIS and the BDF with concerns about defence and security being interchangeably used.

Is there, therefore, the possibility of overlapping responsibilities,

of duplication, unjustified expenditure and a confusion of roles? But from where has this policy emanated? Is it something that has evolved from the DIS? Is it a policy that has been formulated together by the DIS, the BDF and Prisons? Or is it a policy adopted by the Office of the President with or without Parliamentary knowledge and approval?

The question does need an answer because both SADC and its member states, and indeed those beyond, must now be much concerned not just about this country’s determination to increase its military capability but its reason for doing so? How can this country be talking peace with its neighbours when it is convinced that it needs to up its defence capability in anticipation of their possible military aggression?

Would the BDF undertake joint military exercises with its neighbours if this is how it secretly regards them? Yet the DIS Director has spoken with authority and clarity on behalf of both.

What will happen if it is discovered that this alignment between the DIS and the BDF is not what has been suggested? Properly, it needs to be known if the two have different policy objectives and therefore different ideas as to how to back that up?

Is the BDF, as suggested, also preparing to defend the country from the possible aggression not just from neighbouring countries but perhaps of all those south of the Sahara? But then which comes first, the policy or the compulsion to arm which needs some sort of policy to justify it?

How many of those countries currently possess the military capability to attack this one? By narrowing down the possibilities, it would become easy to eliminate the kind of weaponry that would not be needed – such as long range fighter bombers - and the kind that would be essential.

The line between defence and attack is thin and most military weaponry can meet both needs. But then it may be, although I sincerely hope not, that our neighbours have also decided that the best way of defending is to attack. In contrast, it would make much sense for the 14-member countries of SADC to develop an integrated defence, security and intelligence policy and framework. Is it this government’s DIS, however, which has decided to go it alone?

Etcetera II

Banners ?>


Mr. Kennafela. What prompted you to be a politician?

Latest Frontpages

Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper Todays Paper
Adana Escort
Ad─▒yaman Escort
Afyon Escort
A─čr─▒ Escort
Aksaray Escort
Amasya Escort
Ankara Escort
Antalya Escort
Antep Escort
Ardahan Escort
Artvin Escort
Ayd─▒n Escort
Bal─▒kesir Escort
Bart─▒n Escort
Batman Escort
Bayburt Escort
Bilecik Escort
Bing├Âl Escort
Bitlis Escort
Bolu Escort
Burdur Escort
Bursa Escort
Çanakkale Escort
Çankırı Escort
Çorum Escort
Denizli Escort
Diyarbak─▒r Escort
D├╝zce Escort
Edirne Escort
Erzincan Escort
Elaz─▒─č Escort
Erzurum Escort
Eski┼čehir Escort
Giresun Escort
G├╝m├╝┼čhane Escort
Hakkari Escort
Hatay Escort
I─čd─▒r Escort
Isparta Escort
─░skenderun Escort
─░stanbul Escort
─░zmir Escort
─░zmit Escort
Karab├╝k Escort
Karaman Escort
Kars Escort
Kastamonu Escort
Kayseri Escort
K─▒br─▒s Escort
K─▒r─▒kkale Escort
K─▒rklareli Escort
K─▒r┼čehir Escort
Kilis Escort
Kocaeli Escort
Konya Escort
K├╝tahya Escort
Malatya Escort
Manisa Escort
Mara┼č Escort
Mardin Escort
Mersin Escort
Mu─čla Escort
Mu┼č Escort
Nev┼čehir Escort
Ni─čde Escort
Ordu Escort
Osmaniye Escort
Rize Escort
Sakarya Escort
Samsun Escort
Siirt Escort
Sinop Escort
Sivas Escort
┼×─▒rnak Escort
Tekirda─č Escort
Tokat Escort
Trabzon Escort
Tunceli Escort
Urfa Escort
U┼čak Escort
Van Escort
Yalova Escort
Yozgat Escort
Zonguldak Escort
Ala├žat─▒ Escort
Alia─ča Escort
Alsancak Escort
Bornova Escort
Buca Escort
├çe┼čme Escort
├çi─čli Escort
Gaziemir Escort
Kar┼č─▒yaka Escort
fethiye escort
iskenderun escort
iskenderun escort
iskenderun escort
iskenderun escort
iskenderun escort karata┼č escort ceyhan escort ankara escort etimesgut escort ├žankaya escort alt─▒nda─č escort mamak escort ke├ži├Âren escort